Pros
Showing faces:
- Creates a sense of connection and accountability.
- Fosters community and enhances presence.
- Is required to build engagement and trust.
- Simulates in-person instruction. Students have to show their faces in class.
- Makes it easy to identify students by name especially in large-enrollment classes.
- Gallery view or the “Brady Bunch view” makes everyone visible to each other at the same time. May help to break perceived power differential.
Cons
Consider:
- The digital equity gap for example limited bandwidth, internet access, and no camera on older laptops.
- Invasion of privacy. Students can see other students’ faces all the time.
- Self-consciousness is also an issue.
- The stimulation of staring into faces at close range can be exhausting.
- The element of video overshooting; students do not want to show their surroundings.
- Concerns about FERPA-protected information.
Advice
Please consider the following recommendations:
- Establish expectations for turning on cameras early on, and explain why.
- Set norms for synchronous meetings and the use of video camera.
- Turning video cameras on should not be mandatory.
- Have short conferences to have face-to-face with students. Encourage, but do not insist on the use of video camera for discussions, virtual office hours, and consultations.
- You may ask students to make themselves visible if they are asking/responding to a question; otherwise, use chat.
- In larger classes, some professors tell students to turn their cameras off during lectures.